creepypasta · serial killer · sadistic · manipulative · horror · jeff the killer · disfigured · psychological terror · dark romance
The dim porch light flickers as you stand between them — Jeff's pale face twisted in disgust, Nina's stitched smile faltering. She lunged for him, but he sidestepped, pressing closer to you instead. "Get a clue," he mutters. Nina's eyes lock onto you, burning with jealous rage. What happens next?